• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Monday, May 23, 2022
Visit Mawphor
Highland Post
Govt. of Meghalaya
  • Home
  • Meghalaya
    • All
    • East Garo Hills
    • East Jaintia Hills
    • East Khasi Hills
    • Eastern West Khasi Hills
    • North Garo Hills
    • Ri Bhoi
    • South Garo Hills
    • South West Garo Hills
    • South West Khasi Hills
    • Statewide
    • West Garo Hills
    • West Jaintia Hills
    • West Khasi Hills
    DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

    DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

    VPP demands white paper on boundary pact with Assam

    Need for independent inquiry: Ardent

    Inked border pact cannot be revisited: CM

    Conrad rules out repeal of State gambling law

    Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

    Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

    Garo Hills SSA keep up pressure on Govt for release of pending salaries

    FKJGP wants Vaiphei probe report to be made public

    State gets Rs 39.18 cr loan facility from Centre

    State attracts Rs 56.36 crore investment projects in 2020-21

    ‘MDA pinching money from public’s pocket through fuel taxes’

    Petrol, diesel prices reduced

    6 SHGs receiving training on income generation

    6 SHGs receiving training on income generation

    Medical & Sales Reps Union organises health camp

    Medical & Sales Reps Union organises health camp

    Trending Tags

    • North East
    • National
      HYC urges Govt to reduce VAT on petrol, diesel

      Petrol price cut by Rs 9.5, diesel by Rs 7 after govt slashes excise duty; poor to get Rs 200 LPG subsidy

      Provision of UAPA more dangerous than sedition: Retired SC judge Lokur

      Provision of UAPA more dangerous than sedition: Retired SC judge Lokur

      Meghalaya sees 19 pc growth in GST revenue collection in October

      GST council recommendations not binding on Centre, States: SC

    • Health
    • Editorial
    • Sports
    • Writer’s Column
    • Letters to the Editor
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Meghalaya
      • All
      • East Garo Hills
      • East Jaintia Hills
      • East Khasi Hills
      • Eastern West Khasi Hills
      • North Garo Hills
      • Ri Bhoi
      • South Garo Hills
      • South West Garo Hills
      • South West Khasi Hills
      • Statewide
      • West Garo Hills
      • West Jaintia Hills
      • West Khasi Hills
      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      VPP demands white paper on boundary pact with Assam

      Need for independent inquiry: Ardent

      Inked border pact cannot be revisited: CM

      Conrad rules out repeal of State gambling law

      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

      Garo Hills SSA keep up pressure on Govt for release of pending salaries

      FKJGP wants Vaiphei probe report to be made public

      State gets Rs 39.18 cr loan facility from Centre

      State attracts Rs 56.36 crore investment projects in 2020-21

      ‘MDA pinching money from public’s pocket through fuel taxes’

      Petrol, diesel prices reduced

      6 SHGs receiving training on income generation

      6 SHGs receiving training on income generation

      Medical & Sales Reps Union organises health camp

      Medical & Sales Reps Union organises health camp

      Trending Tags

      • North East
      • National
        HYC urges Govt to reduce VAT on petrol, diesel

        Petrol price cut by Rs 9.5, diesel by Rs 7 after govt slashes excise duty; poor to get Rs 200 LPG subsidy

        Provision of UAPA more dangerous than sedition: Retired SC judge Lokur

        Provision of UAPA more dangerous than sedition: Retired SC judge Lokur

        Meghalaya sees 19 pc growth in GST revenue collection in October

        GST council recommendations not binding on Centre, States: SC

      • Health
      • Editorial
      • Sports
      • Writer’s Column
      • Letters to the Editor
      No Result
      View All Result
      Highland Post
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Meghalaya East Khasi Hills

      Despite POCSO Act, child sexual assault victims still have justice denied

      HP News Service by HP News Service
      September 29, 2020
      in East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
      0
      Despite POCSO Act, child sexual assault victims still have justice denied
      0
      SHARES
      212
      VIEWS

      The Protection of Children Against Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act 2012 seems to have gone for a toss in Meghalaya with the rising number of sexual assaults on minors and the long pendency of existing cases.

      Worse than this is when the long wait ends with acquittal for the accused and when the crime is whitewashed with witnesses turning hostile. The helpless child is left unprotected under the pressures of an adult world.

      The matter of a POCSO case (No. 19 of 2015) from Pynursla, East Khasi Hills, which began in 2013 with an FIR and ended six long years later in 2019, is a case in point. All the witnesses, including the estranged step-father of the child victim, turned hostile, leading to the acquittal of the accused. It is one of those cases which show up the police and judicial processes as systems which are failing the child, the POCSO Act notwithstanding. This case stands out as an example of how not to deal with a POCSO case.

      ADVERTISEMENT

      Luckily in this case, some public-spirited relatives are still hoping to challenge the controversial October 31 judgment in a higher court. One of them told Highland Post that “if left unchallenged children will not be safe in their own homes as the adults will connive to exploit them.”

      Who can be blamed if the law is not considered grand and majestic if this child below 12 was a victim of captive rape, which came to light only when, on her complaining of stomach pains, she was taken to the local primary health centre by her mother only to be told that she was in early stage of pregnancy? Her biological father, estranged from the child’s mother, had filed an FIR on February 5, 2013 stating that she has been raped by her step-father and that he had been told of this by his two other daughters, older sisters of the sexually molested child. The FIR also said that the child and her family were threatened. But out of the four family witnesses – the biological father, the mother and two sisters of the victim, all but one turned hostile. The one witness who remained told the special court that the family is financially dependent on the step-father, which is why the others had turned hostile.

      A charge sheet was submitted on July 28, 2014 after nearly a year and a half after the FIR, when the Act says that POCSO trials should be completed within a year.

      Charges were framed on June 20, 2016 under section 5 (j) (ii) (1) (p)/6 of the POCSO Act. Even after the FIR the child seems to have been allowed to stay in the same house as the accused during this entire time, which is against the idea of POCSO Act.

      The child gave birth to a baby boy in Ganesh Das Hospital in November 2013. Once the baby was born, the doctor made a request for a DNA test but the victim and the family refused to undergo one. In fact the complainant, accused and the mother of the victim “informed in writing that they did not want to pursue the matter as they had compromised”. The police stood their ground but police statements are not considered enough in a court of law.

      Since the witnesses turned hostile and they declined the DNA test, the court found no evidence against the accused step-father and acquitted him.

      However, what stands out as a glaring failure of justice is the glossing over of who sexually assaulted the child then? On this point the judge remained silent. The judgment accepts that the witnesses overturned their statements. It did not also acknowledge that the biological father had made a written FIR in the first place which had initiated the investigation by the police. No probe was made into why the man retracted his FIR, just as all the other statements of the witnesses turned hostile were accepted at face value, which is surprising in such a serious child rape case.

      Throughout the entire trial the special public prosecutor under the POCSO Act declined to cross examine the witnesses who turned hostile. In the entire episode, the welfare of the child who became a mother at 12 years of age remained forgotten and unattended.

      It is learnt that she was married off by the mother after the birth of the child, who also now needs protection as the DNA test is still hanging in the air and it is a fact that only a DNA test can finally prove the innocence of the accused.

      Legal experts feel that the very objective of POCSO is undermined when it is not pursued in letter and spirit.

      In December 2019 the Union Minister of Law had written to all the Chief Justices of the High Courts to complete investigation in cases of rape and those registered under the POCSO Act within two months. The Supreme Court had also issued guidelines on speedy disposal of POCSO cases in 2018.

      HP News Service

      HP News Service

      An English daily newspaper from Shillong published by Readington Marwein, proprietor of Mawphor Khasi Daily Newspaper, who established the first Khasi daily in 1989.

      Related Posts

      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses
      Meghalaya

      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      May 23, 2022
      VPP demands white paper on boundary pact with Assam
      Meghalaya

      Need for independent inquiry: Ardent

      May 23, 2022
      Inked border pact cannot be revisited: CM
      Meghalaya

      Conrad rules out repeal of State gambling law

      May 23, 2022
      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai
      West Jaintia Hills

      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

      May 23, 2022
      Garo Hills SSA keep up pressure on Govt for release of pending salaries
      Meghalaya

      FKJGP wants Vaiphei probe report to be made public

      May 23, 2022
      State gets Rs 39.18 cr loan facility from Centre
      Meghalaya

      State attracts Rs 56.36 crore investment projects in 2020-21

      May 23, 2022
      Load More
      Next Post
      “It is okay not to be okay!”

      Tourism and Rural Development

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      We’re on Facebook

      Advertisement

      • Trending
      • Comments
      • Latest
      NEHU co-organises 5-day course on 3D printing

      NEHU reschedules exam after objection from teachers

      May 14, 2022
      M’laya set for six-month long load shedding from March 20

      M’laya set for six-month long load shedding from March 20

      March 17, 2021
      High Court quashes creation of OSD post

      High Court stays all Govt job recruitments in State

      April 5, 2022
      Assistant professor killed in tragic accident

      Assistant professor killed in tragic accident

      October 2, 2021
      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      0

      Two unknown dead bodies recovered

      0

      Weekly market not to reopen in Sutnga Elaka

      0

      Illegal sand, boulder mining along Umiam River banned

      0
      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      May 23, 2022
      VPP demands white paper on boundary pact with Assam

      Need for independent inquiry: Ardent

      May 23, 2022
      Inked border pact cannot be revisited: CM

      Conrad rules out repeal of State gambling law

      May 23, 2022
      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

      May 23, 2022

      Recommended

      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      DOME OF DOOM: New Assembly’s showpiece collapses

      May 23, 2022
      VPP demands white paper on boundary pact with Assam

      Need for independent inquiry: Ardent

      May 23, 2022
      Inked border pact cannot be revisited: CM

      Conrad rules out repeal of State gambling law

      May 23, 2022
      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

      Mohrmen to contest 2023 polls from Jowai

      May 23, 2022

      About Highland Post

      You’re visiting the official website of Highland Post, a leading and most circulated English daily of Meghalaya published by the Mawphor Group. Stay updated with our e-edition for latest updates from Meghalaya, North Eastern India and World as a whole.

      Registered office:
      Mavis Dunn Road, Mawkhar,
      Shillong-793001, Meghalaya
      Phone no: 0364-2545423
      Email: [email protected], [email protected]

      Like Us on Facebook

      Follow Us on Twitter

      Tweets by HP

      © 2021 Highland Post – All Rights Reserved.

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Privacy & Policy
      • Contact
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Meghalaya
        • East Garo Hills
        • East Jaintia Hills
        • East Khasi Hills
        • North Garo Hills
        • Ri Bhoi
        • South Garo Hills
        • South West Garo Hills
        • South West Khasi Hills
        • Statewide
        • West Garo Hills
        • West Jaintia Hills
        • West Khasi Hills
      • North East
      • National
      • International
      • Health
      • Editorial
      • Musey Toons
      • Sports
      • Writer’s Column
      • Letters to the Editor

      © 2021 Highland Post - All Rights Reserved.