By Balakmen Suting
What compels grandmothers to endure Shillong’s November chill, day after day, over a cable car? Not obstinacy, but an arithmetic that every household in this city comprehends: the price of water when it grows scarce.
Since November 6, women from Laban, many of them advanced in years, have kept vigil before the U Kiang Nangbah statue near Civil Hospital. They vow to remain until the government abandons the ₹151-crore Shillong Peak Ropeway. Shillong has not forgotten the parched spell of 2024, when some residents paid between ₹300 and ₹1,000 for water. When these women speak of defending a forest, they speak of the water in their kitchens.
A hill that behaves like a sponge
A forested hill absorbs the monsoon, lets it percolate into the earth, and releases it gradually through springs and streams long after the rains have departed. Lum Shyllong has rendered this service to the city for generations. Scientists at North-Eastern Hill University have described the sacred grove as the source of as many as ten streams. The Joint Action Committee (JAC), which is spearheading the agitation, also cites government records from 1910 acknowledging the need to safeguard the hills and forests around Shillong’s water sources. A colonial administration grasped the bond between forest and water over a century ago. A government in 2026 cannot treat it as a revelation.
The numbers, and what they obscure
By official reckoning, 545 trees have been felled for the project; the women’s groups put the figure at 544. The discrepancy of a single tree is immaterial. Even on the government’s own count, hundreds of mature trees have been cleared from a catchment slope, and the protesters’ anxiety runs deeper than any tally. They ask what becomes of the hill’s capacity to retain and release water once its canopy is gone.
The government replies that the alignment has been kept clear of key catchment areas and that compensatory plantation is under way. Meghalaya Tourism has reaffirmed that statutory clearances are in place. These are weighty assurances and merit serious consideration. Yet the women’s rejoinder is equally reasonable. The gap between a ropeway tower and a spring is not a measure of the safety of an entire hydrological system, and saplings planted elsewhere cannot substitute for a mature forest standing in the same catchment.
The protesters further allege that a stream behind the site, once perennial through monsoon and winter, has run dry since the felling. That remains their claim, and the government maintains that the water sources are secure. A claim of this kind is testable, and the public should not be asked to adjudicate it on faith.
The question that remains unanswered
When officials declare the project distant from the water sources, what precisely was measured? Was it merely the distance from a spring to a tower, or the entire catchment that feeds the springs and streams below? A line on a map reveals nothing about how water moves through a landscape. It travels underground, through soil and fractured rock, along channels that no survey line follows.
This is a question of method, and its remedy is plain: a hydrological study of the whole catchment, conducted by independent experts and published in full. If the project is as safe as claimed, such a study would be the government’s most formidable defence. If it cannot be produced, the assurance of safety has not been established.
A standoff that has hardened
The impasse has only deepened. A stakeholders’ meeting on November 11 ended in uproar, and the next day Deputy Chief Minister Prestone Tynsong rejected demands to scrap or relocate the project, urging protesters to examine the government’s technical findings. That invitation deserves acceptance, but on terms of independent verification, not unilateral presentation.
Consultation and consent
The JAC contends that residents were not adequately consulted and that their concerns regarding customary land rights and environmental impact were never properly addressed. These are grave allegations in a state where community ownership and traditional institutions are woven into the governance of land. The Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council halted the project on October 27 over alleged licensing violations, yet the site was unsealed on November 4. When a tribal council and a state department diverge on whether the licensing is in order, the difference should be resolved transparently, not overridden.
Not against development
Observers beyond the Northeast may sigh, “Here we go again, another community resisting development.” That would be a profound misreading. These women do not oppose better roads or improved public infrastructure, nor do they oppose Shillong’s future. Their objection is to this ropeway at this location. They seek its cancellation, not its relocation within the same catchment, because the catchment is the crux of the matter.
What a confident government would do
A government assured of its case has no need of barricades. It would commission an independent, catchment-wide study and publish every clearance together with its reasoning. It would suspend work until the findings are public, and it would sit down with the JAC, the Dorbars and the residents who depend on this water before decisions are taken, not after.
Shillong needs tourism and livelihoods. It also needs water, and the case for a ropeway is only as strong as the evidence that the hill’s water is safe. The grandmothers of Laban have posed a plain question to the state. Those who will drink the water deserve a plain answer before another tree falls.























