By Synshar Marwein
How strong is our society today? Are we still afraid to question the Government, the courts and those holding positions of authority? Have we become so indifferent that we no longer wish to understand the issues affecting our society? Or have we simply lost the courage to stand up for what is right?
Not every issue affects everyone equally. Some directly affect us, while others may seem distant from our personal interests. But does that mean we should remain silent? A responsible society must be concerned not only with its immediate problems but also with issues that may determine its future.
Today, I wish to draw attention to one such issue: the future of the Deficit System and the plight of deficit teachers and employees in Meghalaya.
Understanding the Deficit System
The Deficit System covers primary, upper primary, secondary and higher secondary schools, as well as colleges. It includes both teaching and non-teaching employees.
Inherited from undivided Assam, this system has continued to serve Meghalaya for decades. These institutions are managed by their respective Management Committees, which oversee administration and recruitment, while the Government provides salaries through the deficit grant mechanism.
An important fact that many people overlook is that deficit posts are sanctioned posts carrying prescribed pay scales, from primary schools to colleges.
Although the system has certain disadvantages, including concerns over regular salary payments and reimbursements, it has provided an established employment structure and contributed significantly to education in Meghalaya.
It is also much older than subsequent arrangements such as Adhoc and SSA. Therefore, its history and contribution cannot simply be ignored when discussing educational reforms.
The Rivet Popper Hypothesis: A Warning Against Gradual Destruction
The present situation reminds me of the Rivet Popper Hypothesis, proposed by ecologist Paul Ehrlich.
The hypothesis compares an aeroplane to an ecosystem and its rivets to the different species that sustain it. Removing one rivet may not immediately affect the aircraft, but gradually removing more rivets can weaken its entire structure. Eventually, the aircraft may become unsafe.
The same principle applies to an ecosystem: the gradual disappearance of species can threaten its overall stability.
The Deficit System may be facing a similar situation.
The introduction of the Structured Pay Framework (SPF), delays in Dearness Allowance (DA), failure to advertise vacant posts, the CPF Scheme of 2026 and other unresolved service matters must not be viewed as isolated issues.
When considered together, these developments raise serious concerns about the future of the system.
What appears to be a series of separate administrative decisions may gradually weaken an established institution. If we fail to recognise these warning signs, we may eventually witness the disappearance of a system that has served generations.
More Than a Service Matter: An Employment and Educational Issue
The Deficit System is not merely about the salaries and service conditions of existing employees. It has also provided employment to countless educated youths over the decades.
At a time when securing regular government employment is increasingly difficult, deficit institutions have offered an alternative opportunity for educated individuals to enter the teaching profession.
The system has also sustained hundreds of educational institutions and their respective Management Committees.
Therefore, protecting the Deficit System is not simply about protecting existing employees. It is about preserving an employment framework and an educational structure for future generations.
The Indefinite Strike: Where Is the Government’s Accountability?
The indefinite strike launched by the KJDSTA on 11 November 2026 reflects the growing frustration among deficit teachers and employees.
Despite repeated meetings, discussions and engagements with Government representatives, their grievances remain unresolved.
The Government cannot continue to respond to serious issues with verbal assurances while delaying concrete decisions. Employees are entitled to clear answers, definite commitments and timely action.
A government is judged by what it delivers, not by the promises it repeatedly makes.
The longer these matters remain unresolved, the deeper the frustration and uncertainty will become.
Students Must Not Become Victims of Government Inaction
With the academic year approaching its end and examinations around the corner, prolonged disruption to teaching is a serious concern.
Students should not have to bear the consequences of an unresolved dispute between employees and the Government.
But we must ask: Who should take responsibility for bringing the situation to this point?
Should parents blame teachers? Should Management Committees bear the entire burden? Or should the Government accept responsibility for failing to resolve the grievances?
Teachers are not protesting because they wish to deprive children of education. They have spent an entire academic year teaching, guiding and preparing students for their future. Their agitation is a result of unresolved grievances, not a lack of concern for their pupils.
An Appeal to Parents and Management Committees
To all parents, I ask: Will you blame the teachers who have educated your children throughout the year, or will you stand with them and question why the Government has failed to address their concerns?
Teachers and parents should not become opponents. They share a common responsibility towards the future of children.
The Government must not be allowed to escape accountability by creating divisions between parents and teachers.
To the various School Management Committees, do not remain indifferent. Your institutions depend on the dedication and service of their employees. Although the institutions are managed by you, the Government is responsible for providing the prescribed deficit salaries.
If you share the benefits of the Deficit System, you must also share the responsibility of protecting it.
Do not expect teachers and employees to carry the entire burden of this struggle while others simply wait to enjoy its benefits.
An Appeal to the Educated Youth
To the educated and unemployed youths of Meghalaya, this issue concerns you too.
The Deficit System has provided employment opportunities to generations of people. Those fighting for its survival are not demanding privileges at the expense of others. They want the system to continue so that future generations may also have opportunities to work and contribute to society.
You may not be directly affected today, but its future could affect your opportunities tomorrow.
Protecting Education Means Protecting the System
Deficit schools and colleges have contributed significantly to the educational development of Meghalaya. If there are shortcomings, the Government should address them through better infrastructure, teacher training, accountability and academic support.A system that has served generations should not be dismantled without proper consultation, transparency and convincing justification.
The Time to Speak Is Now
To parents, students, teachers, non-teaching employees, Management Committees and unemployed youths: this struggle is bigger than the demands of one particular group.
It concerns an established educational and employment system that has served Meghalaya for decades.
The Rivet Popper Hypothesis teaches us that removing one rivet may appear harmless, but the gradual removal of many can eventually threaten the entire structure.
The same warning applies to the Deficit System. SPF, DA delays, vacant posts, CPF-related concerns and other unresolved matters must not be ignored as separate administrative problems.
If we remain silent today while the system is gradually weakened, we may have nothing left to protect tomorrow.
The teachers and employees are fighting not only for their present rights but also for the continuation of a system that has served generations and deserves a future.
Protect the Deficit System. Protect the rights of teachers and employees. Protect the future of education and employment in Meghalaya. Let us not wait until the rivets are gone before realising the importance of the aircraft.























