• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Sunday, May 28, 2023
Visit Mawphor
Highland Post
Govt. of Meghalaya
  • Home
  • Meghalaya
    • All
    • East Garo Hills
    • East Jaintia Hills
    • East Khasi Hills
    • Eastern West Khasi Hills
    • North Garo Hills
    • Ri Bhoi
    • South Garo Hills
    • South West Garo Hills
    • South West Khasi Hills
    • Statewide
    • West Garo Hills
    • West Jaintia Hills
    • West Khasi Hills
    Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

    Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

    KHNAM demands Govt to speak out against allegations

    Reservation roster registers, accounts vital documents: KHNAM

    Congress for review of reservation policy

    Congress for review of reservation policy

    CM presents State’s identified growth engines at NITI Aayog meet

    CM presents State’s identified growth engines at NITI Aayog meet

    Section 144 CrPC promulgated at Sohra’s Dainthlen, Wei-Sawdong

    Section 144 CrPC promulgated at Sohra’s Dainthlen, Wei-Sawdong

    Villagers fear risk of being cut off as border fence nears completion

    Congress MLA urges Govt to defer second phase of border talks

    Dr Andreas Dkhar no more

    Dr Andreas Dkhar no more

    CM presents State’s vision to be a $10 Billion economy to World Bank

    CM presents State’s vision to be a $10 Billion economy to World Bank

    Dacoits decamp with over Rs 25,000 after assaulting couple

    ACHIK appeals church leaders to engage youth in nation building

    Trending Tags

    • North East
    • National
      PM Modi urges states to maintain fiscal discipline, take prudent decisions

      PM Modi urges states to maintain fiscal discipline, take prudent decisions

      India lost over 1.3 lakh lives in disasters linked to extreme weather, climate change in 50 years: UN agency

      India lost over 1.3 lakh lives in disasters linked to extreme weather, climate change in 50 years: UN agency

      IAF temporarily grounds MiG-21 squadrons

      IAF temporarily grounds MiG-21 squadrons

    • Health
    • Editorial
    • Sports
    • Writer’s Column
    • Letters to the Editor
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Meghalaya
      • All
      • East Garo Hills
      • East Jaintia Hills
      • East Khasi Hills
      • Eastern West Khasi Hills
      • North Garo Hills
      • Ri Bhoi
      • South Garo Hills
      • South West Garo Hills
      • South West Khasi Hills
      • Statewide
      • West Garo Hills
      • West Jaintia Hills
      • West Khasi Hills
      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      KHNAM demands Govt to speak out against allegations

      Reservation roster registers, accounts vital documents: KHNAM

      Congress for review of reservation policy

      Congress for review of reservation policy

      CM presents State’s identified growth engines at NITI Aayog meet

      CM presents State’s identified growth engines at NITI Aayog meet

      Section 144 CrPC promulgated at Sohra’s Dainthlen, Wei-Sawdong

      Section 144 CrPC promulgated at Sohra’s Dainthlen, Wei-Sawdong

      Villagers fear risk of being cut off as border fence nears completion

      Congress MLA urges Govt to defer second phase of border talks

      Dr Andreas Dkhar no more

      Dr Andreas Dkhar no more

      CM presents State’s vision to be a $10 Billion economy to World Bank

      CM presents State’s vision to be a $10 Billion economy to World Bank

      Dacoits decamp with over Rs 25,000 after assaulting couple

      ACHIK appeals church leaders to engage youth in nation building

      Trending Tags

      • North East
      • National
        PM Modi urges states to maintain fiscal discipline, take prudent decisions

        PM Modi urges states to maintain fiscal discipline, take prudent decisions

        India lost over 1.3 lakh lives in disasters linked to extreme weather, climate change in 50 years: UN agency

        India lost over 1.3 lakh lives in disasters linked to extreme weather, climate change in 50 years: UN agency

        IAF temporarily grounds MiG-21 squadrons

        IAF temporarily grounds MiG-21 squadrons

      • Health
      • Editorial
      • Sports
      • Writer’s Column
      • Letters to the Editor
      No Result
      View All Result
      Highland Post
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Writer's Column

      Reservation and Roster: VVP and Anti-VPP: Laziness par excellence

      By Dr. Bhogtoram Mawroh

      HP News Service by HP News Service
      May 1, 2023
      in Writer's Column
      0
      The battle for ballot in the North-East
      0
      SHARES
      1.7k
      VIEWS

      I was in two minds about whether to write this article or not. When the author of the article ‘Reservation and Roster: VVP and Anti-VPP’ misconstrued the article that I had written for The Shillong Times, ‘Who Deserves Reservation: Khasi-Jaintia or Garo?’ my initial reaction was to ignore it. After all, this is the age of digital media, where content once made public will forever become part of the digital repository.

      So, for those who might have been intrigued by the claims made about my article, they could always go and check it out on their own. This way, they will realise for themselves that the conclusions drawn from my article are not only misleading but amount to downright malice. But then I realise that the reason the author thought he could get away with making wrong claims about my article is the same reason he expected no one would verify his claims: laziness.

      I don’t think the author had any ill-intentions towards me that compelled him to write the piece where he made misleading claims about my article. It’s just that he wanted to push an agenda of his own, and he saw my article – at least the title, I think – and decided to use it as a straw man to buttress his own claims. So what were those claims? Let’s take a look.

      I am extracting the passage directly from his own article so that I cannot be accused of misconstruing his words. I wouldn’t want to be blamed for something I have been made a victim of. So in his article, he has claimed that “articles with a subject such as “Who Deserves Reservation: Khasi-Jaintia or Garo?” and with illogical claims that Khasis no longer need a reservation to show to the world that they can compete with anyone are baseless arguments of nothing but self-aggrandisement”. So there are two parts to this statement that I would like to discuss: the first is the claim that I believe that Khasis no longer need reservation, and the second is that my arguments are attempts at self-aggrandisement. Let’s take the first one.

      In my article ‘Who Deserves Reservation: Khasi-Jaintia or Garo?’ I made the argument that reservation in India is derived from Clauses (4) and (4A) of Article 16 of the Indian Constitution, which mention that the State can make provisions for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of backward classes of citizens that, in the opinion of the State, are not adequately represented in the services under the State.

      The focus here, therefore, is on backwardness and lack of representation in jobs (services), not demography, which is being touted as the reason for reviewing the 40:40 formula of the current reservation policy. So, the question that arises is how to measure backwardness, which will form the basis on which reservations will be made. However, I did not ignore the point of demography, which I would later incorporate to come up with a revised formula of my own that takes into consideration both the issue of backwardness and demography.

      There are many ways to measure backwardness. One is the Human Development Index (HDI), developed by Pakistani economist Mahbub ul Haq in 1990, while the other is the Multi Dimensional Poverty Index (MDPI), developed in 2010 by the Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI) and the United Nations Development Programme. Then there are the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG), 17 goals in all, that attempt to provide a blueprint to achieve a better and more sustainable future for all.

      Among the three, the SDGs are the most comprehensive. This is because both HDI and MDPI attempt to measure the dimensions of health, education, and standard of living (the former at the aggregate level while the latter at the micro level), all three of which are part of the SDG, and much more. In fact, in the ‘North Eastern Region: District SDG Index, Report, and Dashboard Baseline Report 2021-2022’ prepared by NITI Aayog, SDG 1: No Poverty has listed MDPI as one of the indicators for measuring progress towards the goal.

      This is the reason I chose the SDG as the framework to measure backwardness among the Khasi-Jaintia and Garo in Meghalaya. My aim was to see, based on backwardness, who is in greater need of reservation, the Khasi-Jaintia or the Garo, but not who doesn’t need reservation.

      I used the ranks of individual districts (aggregated into two groups, Khasi-Jaintia and Garo) to measure their performance on SDGs and found that “when all the SDGs are considered, the average rank achieved by the Khasi-Jaintia districts is 75, while the Garo districts get 85, i.e., a difference of 10 ranks”. In fact, my analysis of the report (which is available in public for others to do the same) revealed that “the Khasi-Jaintia districts have performed better than the Garo districts in ten SDGs, i.e., 66 per cent of the total SDGs. This reveals the clear gap in terms of development between the two regions”.

      Since reservation is based on backwardness, the Garos are in greater need of reservation than the Khasi-Jaintia, but that does not mean the latter does not need it. So, taking the argument of demographics, I gave the Garo “a share based on their demographic size, i.e., 31 per cent. However, in order to correct for the historical injustice (backwardness as brought out by the SDGs), a figure of 10 per cent (difference in rank) should be added, which will take the figure to 41 per cent. As for the Khasi-Jaintia, their share will be reduced to 36 per cent because the combined size of the Khasi-Jaintia and Garo populations is 77 per cent, not 80 per cent. This can be reviewed every few years upon the release of fresh data”.

      So as one can see from the extracts that I have used from my original article, ‘Who Deserves Reservation: Khasi-Jaintia or Garo?’ I did not say that “Khasis no longer need a reservation”, only that the Garo need more. So why did the author try to misrepresent my article? In fact, the author goes on to say that “if one opines that any of these communities do not need a reservation, then he or she has directly questioned the wisdom of the founders of the state Reservation Policy and also speak against the decision of the Hon’ble High Court concerning the Roster system”.

      The simple answer is that the author in question did not read my article but simply saw the title and decided he already knew what the content was. Reading the article meant spending at least ten minutes and then reflecting on it, which, depending on comprehension capacity, will take a few minutes to a couple of hours. In short, it would take too much of his valuable time. Since he already had an agenda to push, and people usually like to tell people what they want rather than listen to what others are actually saying, the result was the utterly misleading article ‘Reservation and Roster: VVP and Anti-VPP’.

      Now that we have established that the argument made by the author about my article is misleading, it is clear that his claim in his article that my arguments are baseless and “nothing but self-aggrandisement” is nothing but a perfect example of ad hominem, Latin for “to the man,” attacking the arguer and not the argument. This is not the only one, and there are many more such tricks that are used to mislead people.

      I have already mentioned the straw man at the beginning. Those who would like to know more about such devious tricks (maybe they can use them on others) can read the article ‘The Baloney (nonsense) Detection Kit: Carl Sagan’s Rules for Bullshit-Busting and Critical Thinking’. Just type this title, and Google will take you to the page where you can find more tricks like the one the author tried to use on me.

      There are many problems with the article ‘Reservation and Roster: VVP and Anti-VPP’, not least the ones I have identified. But then writing on them will require multiple rejoinders, so I will leave that for the future. The only thing I would ask of the readers of this article is that they should not believe my words but can go and review my article, ‘Who Deserves Reservation: Khasi-Jaintia or Garo?’ on their own. They can also analyse the NITI Aayog ‘North Eastern Region: District SDG Index, Report, and Dashboard Baseline Report 2021-2022’ (which is publicly available), on which my reasoning for giving a higher share to the Garo rests.

      The Khasi will not lose their reservation but will get a reduced share. There are those who may not agree with it, but it’s up to them to argue otherwise, and that is perfectly alright. We live in a democracy where everyone has the right to express their views. However, they have to be based on facts and not misrepresentation or ad hominem attacks. That is a lazy approach that is not really attractive. So please avoid that.

      (The views expressed in the article are those of the author and do not reflect in any way his affiliation to any organisation or institution)

      HP News Service

      HP News Service

      An English daily newspaper from Shillong published by Readington Marwein, proprietor of Mawphor Khasi Daily Newspaper, who established the first Khasi daily in 1989.

      Related Posts

      The battle for ballot in the North-East
      Writer's Column

      Reservation, Backwardness and Population

      May 27, 2023
      The battle for ballot in the North-East
      Writer's Column

      Meghalaya still a Sub-State of Assam?

      May 23, 2023
      The battle for ballot in the North-East
      Writer's Column

      Meghalaya a powerless State

      May 22, 2023
      The battle for ballot in the North-East
      Writer's Column

      MDA-2 Government, don’t take the public for granted

      May 19, 2023
      The battle for ballot in the North-East
      Writer's Column

      Khasi Heritage: The Cradle of Khasi Culture

      May 16, 2023
      The battle for ballot in the North-East
      Writer's Column

      Manipur: A Chronicle of Pain and Suffering

      May 15, 2023
      Load More
      Next Post
      Nepotism – the executioner of bright deserving minds.

      Revive the Bamboo Mission

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      We’re on Facebook

      Advertisement

      • Trending
      • Comments
      • Latest
      Cars with tinted glasses have a free run on roads

      Cars with tinted glasses have a free run on roads

      June 12, 2022
      NEHU co-organises 5-day course on 3D printing

      NEHU reschedules exam after objection from teachers

      May 14, 2022
      M’laya set for six-month long load shedding from March 20

      M’laya set for six-month long load shedding from March 20

      March 17, 2021
      North Garo Hills villagers petition CM for water supply

      3-days water cut in city from Mar 29

      March 27, 2023
      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      0

      Two unknown dead bodies recovered

      0

      Weekly market not to reopen in Sutnga Elaka

      0

      Illegal sand, boulder mining along Umiam River banned

      0
      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      May 27, 2023
      KHNAM demands Govt to speak out against allegations

      Reservation roster registers, accounts vital documents: KHNAM

      May 27, 2023
      Congress for review of reservation policy

      Congress for review of reservation policy

      May 27, 2023
      Army chief arrives in Manipur on two-day visit to review ground situation

      Army chief arrives in Manipur on two-day visit to review ground situation

      May 27, 2023

      Recommended

      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      Govt notifies committee on job quota roster system; Ardent rejects being part

      May 27, 2023
      KHNAM demands Govt to speak out against allegations

      Reservation roster registers, accounts vital documents: KHNAM

      May 27, 2023
      Congress for review of reservation policy

      Congress for review of reservation policy

      May 27, 2023
      Army chief arrives in Manipur on two-day visit to review ground situation

      Army chief arrives in Manipur on two-day visit to review ground situation

      May 27, 2023

      About Highland Post

      You’re visiting the official website of Highland Post, a leading and most circulated English daily of Meghalaya published by the Mawphor Group. Stay updated with our e-edition for latest updates from Meghalaya, North Eastern India and World as a whole.

      Registered office:
      Mavis Dunn Road, Mawkhar,
      Shillong-793001, Meghalaya
      Phone no: 0364-2545423
      Email: highlandpost.shg@gmail.com, editorhp2019@gmail.com

      Like Us on Facebook

      Follow Us on Twitter

      Tweets by HP

      © 2021 Highland Post – All Rights Reserved.

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Privacy & Policy
      • Contact
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Meghalaya
        • East Garo Hills
        • East Jaintia Hills
        • East Khasi Hills
        • North Garo Hills
        • Ri Bhoi
        • South Garo Hills
        • South West Garo Hills
        • South West Khasi Hills
        • Statewide
        • West Garo Hills
        • West Jaintia Hills
        • West Khasi Hills
      • North East
      • National
      • International
      • Health
      • Editorial
      • Musey Toons
      • Sports
      • Writer’s Column
      • Letters to the Editor

      © 2021 Highland Post - All Rights Reserved.