• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Visit Mawphor
Highland Post
Govt. of Meghalaya
  • Home
  • Meghalaya
    • All
    • East Garo Hills
    • East Jaintia Hills
    • East Khasi Hills
    • Eastern West Khasi Hills
    • North Garo Hills
    • Ri Bhoi
    • South Garo Hills
    • South West Garo Hills
    • South West Khasi Hills
    • Statewide
    • West Garo Hills
    • West Jaintia Hills
    • West Khasi Hills
    CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

    CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

    New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

    New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

    DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

    DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

    2 men sentenced to 14 years in jail for rape

    3 get 20 years in POCSO cases

    Meghalaya Speaker felicitated at House of Lords

    Meghalaya Speaker felicitated at House of Lords

    State BJP prez attends national office-bearers meet on 2024 poll preparedness

    BJP wave incoming? More MLAs, MDCs keen on joining State Prez says

    Govt broke DA promise: Deficit teachers to intensify stir

    KJDSTA to strike from Wednesday over Govt’s ‘failure’ to implement demands

    Daistong: Two sides, two stories

    KSU lodges FIR into Daistong confrontation

    City lawyer says grandson not victim of accidental drug overdose but murder

    City lawyer says grandson not victim of accidental drug overdose but murder

    Trending Tags

    • North East
    • National
      SC refuses to stay Meghalaya HC order granting bail to Sonam Raghuvanshi

      SC rejects plea for guidelines on appointment of ministers facing criminal charges

      SC quashes all FIRs against CJP protesters; Sept 5 march called off

      24-hour arrest deadline begins from detention, not formal arrest: SC

      Major overhaul in Agnipath scheme; Govt grants 2-year extension, opens pathway to permanent recruitment

      Major overhaul in Agnipath scheme; Govt grants 2-year extension, opens pathway to permanent recruitment

    • Health
    • Editorial
    • Sports
    • Writer’s Column
    • Letters to the Editor
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Meghalaya
      • All
      • East Garo Hills
      • East Jaintia Hills
      • East Khasi Hills
      • Eastern West Khasi Hills
      • North Garo Hills
      • Ri Bhoi
      • South Garo Hills
      • South West Garo Hills
      • South West Khasi Hills
      • Statewide
      • West Garo Hills
      • West Jaintia Hills
      • West Khasi Hills
      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      2 men sentenced to 14 years in jail for rape

      3 get 20 years in POCSO cases

      Meghalaya Speaker felicitated at House of Lords

      Meghalaya Speaker felicitated at House of Lords

      State BJP prez attends national office-bearers meet on 2024 poll preparedness

      BJP wave incoming? More MLAs, MDCs keen on joining State Prez says

      Govt broke DA promise: Deficit teachers to intensify stir

      KJDSTA to strike from Wednesday over Govt’s ‘failure’ to implement demands

      Daistong: Two sides, two stories

      KSU lodges FIR into Daistong confrontation

      City lawyer says grandson not victim of accidental drug overdose but murder

      City lawyer says grandson not victim of accidental drug overdose but murder

      Trending Tags

      • North East
      • National
        SC refuses to stay Meghalaya HC order granting bail to Sonam Raghuvanshi

        SC rejects plea for guidelines on appointment of ministers facing criminal charges

        SC quashes all FIRs against CJP protesters; Sept 5 march called off

        24-hour arrest deadline begins from detention, not formal arrest: SC

        Major overhaul in Agnipath scheme; Govt grants 2-year extension, opens pathway to permanent recruitment

        Major overhaul in Agnipath scheme; Govt grants 2-year extension, opens pathway to permanent recruitment

      • Health
      • Editorial
      • Sports
      • Writer’s Column
      • Letters to the Editor
      No Result
      View All Result
      Highland Post
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home National

      Courts cannot fix timeline for governor, Prez to give assent to bills passed by assembly: SC

      HP News Service by HP News Service
      November 21, 2025
      in National
      0
      SC proposes to stay key provisions of Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025

      Supreme Court of India: Photo PTI

      0
      SHARES
      102
      VIEWS

      New Delhi, Nov 20: In a significant verdict, the Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that timelines cannot be fixed for the governor and the President for giving assent to bills passed by state assemblies and the judiciary cannot also grant deemed assent to them.

      A five-judge Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice BR Gavai unanimously held that it would be against the interest of federalism, if the Governor without following due process under Article 200 (power to governor to provide assent to bills passed by assembly), is allowed to withhold bills.

      The bench also comprising Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P S Narasimha and A S Chandurkar said, “We don’t think governors have unfettered power to sit over bills passed by state assemblies”.

      While answering the Presidential reference in which President Droupadi Murmu has sought the opinion of apex court under Article 143 (1) of the Constitution, the bench said that governors have three options — either to grant assent or send bills for reconsideration or refer them to the President.

      It said in a democratic country like India, fixing timelines for governors is against elasticity provided by the Constitution.

      The top court also deprecated the grant of “deemed assent” granted by the apex court on April 8 in the case of Tamil Nadu to the bills held by the state governor, saying it amounts to virtually taking over functions of constitutional authority.

      The top court also ruled that the discharge of Governor’s power under Article 200 is not justiciable.

       

      Mixed views from legal experts, Oppn leaders

      Legal experts and leaders of some opposition-ruled states on Thursday expressed mixed views on the Supreme Court’s opinion on the Presidential Reference that no timelines can be prescribed for governors and the president in granting assent to bills passed by assemblies.

      West Bengal Assembly Speaker Biman Banerjee said a bill loses significance when it remains stuck without clarity, adding that he “personally feels” that a fixed timeline should be laid down for governors to clear bills. He argued that keeping legislation pending indefinitely defeats the purpose of lawmaking and leaves elected governments in limbo.

      The ruling DMK in Tamil Nadu on Thursday termed the verdict of the Supreme Court on governors as a “good judgment” and that it would be useful in other cases involving powers of the gubernatorial post. Senior DMK leader T K S Elangovan said that if the state assembly elected by the people of Tamil Nadu had passed a resolution, the governor has to accept it.

      Communist Party of India (Marxist) general secretary M A Baby said the Supreme Court’s response to the Presidential Reference on timelines to grant assent to bills was “deplorable and shocking”.

      Senior advocate Vikas Pahwa said the ruling effectively rolls back the “rigid timelines” of three months for the constitutional functionaries imposed in April by a two-judge bench of the apex court.

      “While the Supreme Court continues to guard against prolonged, unexplained and indefinite delays in clearing the bills, it duly respects the governor’s and president’s constitutional discretion — allowing more space for dialogue, rather than forcing every decision into a judicially mandated deadline,” he said.

      Terming the opinion as a “corrective intervention”, Pahwa said the April 8 verdict had sought to curb the “pocket veto” or permanent inaction by the governors “but, in doing so, arguably pushed the judiciary into micromanaging constitutional actors”.

      He said the opinion of the Constitution bench restores a more balanced approach.

      On the fate of the 10 Tamil Nadu legislations, which were granted deemed assent by the top court on April 8 by exercising its plenary power under Article 142, senior advocate Amit Anand Tiwari said all those bills have become laws and are already notified in the Gazette.

      “The opinion rendered in the Presidential Reference will have no impact on the Acts which have already been notified in pursuance of the judgment dated April 8, 2025,” he said.

      Justice J B Pardiwala-led bench on April 8 had granted deemed assent to 10 Tamil Nadu bills.

      The bills, which have now become laws, included amendments to Tamil Nadu Fisheries University Act, Tamil Nadu Veterinary and Animal Sciences University Act, Chennai University Act and Tamil Nadu Dr. Ambedkar Law University Act.

      Tiwari said the April 8 verdict in Tamil Nadu case has attained finality. He referred to a judgment to buttress his point that the subsequent advisory opinion of the Supreme Court on a Presidential Reference cannot overturn the earlier judgment.

      However, the apex court’s opinion referred to the views of Justice Y V Chandrachud in a 1978 Presidential Reference case in which he had held that all the courts are bound by the view expressed by the apex court “even in the exercise of its advisory jurisdiction under Article 143(1) of the Constitution”.

      Advocate Ashwani Dubey said the core finding of the April 8 judgment which prescribed specific timelines has been set aside by the opinion.

      “The ‘deemed assent’ granted by the apex court itself on the 10 Tamil Nadu bills via its Article 142 powers is likely void or significantly affected by the Constitution Bench’s ruling that ‘deemed assent’ is impermissible,” Dubey said. (PTI)

      HP News Service

      HP News Service

      An English daily newspaper from Shillong published by Readington Marwein, proprietor of Mawphor Khasi Daily Newspaper, who established the first Khasi daily in 1989.

      Related Posts

      SC refuses to stay Meghalaya HC order granting bail to Sonam Raghuvanshi
      National

      SC rejects plea for guidelines on appointment of ministers facing criminal charges

      November 7, 2026
      SC quashes all FIRs against CJP protesters; Sept 5 march called off
      National

      24-hour arrest deadline begins from detention, not formal arrest: SC

      November 6, 2026
      Major overhaul in Agnipath scheme; Govt grants 2-year extension, opens pathway to permanent recruitment
      National

      Major overhaul in Agnipath scheme; Govt grants 2-year extension, opens pathway to permanent recruitment

      November 4, 2026
      CEO urged to include Khasi-Jaintia villages in M’laya electoral rolls
      National

      Old voters can file Form 6 if names missing in draft SIR rolls; no prosecution: EC

      November 3, 2026
      ‘Try CEC For Treason’: INDIA Bloc’s symbolic impeachment
      National

      ‘Try CEC For Treason’: INDIA Bloc’s symbolic impeachment

      November 1, 2026
      Keep Rahul as ‘Mock PM’ for life: BJP to Opposition
      National

      Keep Rahul as ‘Mock PM’ for life: BJP to Opposition

      November 1, 2026
      Load More
      Next Post
      Sale of Nitrazepam tablets banned

      The Perils of Self-Prescription

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      We’re on Facebook

      Advertisement

      • Trending
      • Comments
      • Latest
      Sonam & Raja were with 3 other tourists on day they vanished, says tour guide

      Sonam & Raja were with 3 other tourists on day they vanished, says tour guide

      June 7, 2025
      Tourist taxi association launches agitation against outside vehicles

      Tourist taxi association launches agitation against outside vehicles

      September 17, 2025
      Residents of 44 localities in Shillong drink unsafe water

      Residents of 44 localities in Shillong drink unsafe water

      October 3, 2023
      Bike taxi drivers ask Govt for offline option

      Rapido captains caught off guard by DTO, hired and fined

      July 7, 2024
      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      0
      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      0
      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      0
      2 men sentenced to 14 years in jail for rape

      3 get 20 years in POCSO cases

      0
      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      November 10, 2026
      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      November 10, 2026
      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      November 10, 2026
      2 men sentenced to 14 years in jail for rape

      3 get 20 years in POCSO cases

      November 10, 2026

      Recommended

      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      CM lays foundation for Rongjeng complex, road

      November 10, 2026
      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      New building for Khlur Rit school 5 years after landslide

      November 10, 2026
      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      DLSA takes legal aid awareness to Nongstoiñ market

      November 10, 2026
      2 men sentenced to 14 years in jail for rape

      3 get 20 years in POCSO cases

      November 10, 2026

      About Highland Post

      You’re visiting the official website of Highland Post, a leading and most circulated English daily of Meghalaya published by the Mawphor Group. Stay updated with our e-edition for latest updates from Meghalaya, North Eastern India and World as a whole.

      Registered office:
      Mavis Dunn Road, Mawkhar,
      Shillong-793001, Meghalaya
      Phone no: 0364-2545423
      Email: highlandpost.shg@gmail.com, editorhp2019@gmail.com

      Like Us on Facebook

      Follow Us on Twitter

      Tweets by HP

      © 2021 Highland Post – All Rights Reserved.

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Privacy & Policy
      • Contact
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Meghalaya
        • East Garo Hills
        • East Jaintia Hills
        • East Khasi Hills
        • North Garo Hills
        • Ri Bhoi
        • South Garo Hills
        • South West Garo Hills
        • South West Khasi Hills
        • Statewide
        • West Garo Hills
        • West Jaintia Hills
        • West Khasi Hills
      • North East
      • National
      • International
      • Health
      • Editorial
      • Musey Toons
      • Sports
      • Writer’s Column
      • Letters to the Editor

      © 2021 Highland Post - All Rights Reserved.