Shillong, Nov 17: In a judgment that will govern law-making in all three Autonomous District Councils in Meghalaya, the Meghalaya High Court has struck down the Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) (Amendment) Act, 2019, for violation of mandatory legislative procedure.
A division bench of Justice Hamarsan Singh Thangkhiew and Justice Biswadeep Bhattacharjee on Tuesday declared the Amendment ultra vires for a fatal departure from Rule 93 of the Assam and Meghalaya Autonomous Districts (Constitution of District Councils) Rules, 1951.
The petition was filed by Tolentine Wahlang of Nonglynkien and Haspingwel Kharhari of Mawtiehbah, both under Hima Maharam in South West Khasi Hills.
The Principal Act of 2006 lays down the procedure for nomination and election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam. The Amendment Bill, passed by the KHADC on July 25, 2019, sought to change the law for Raid Saw Symper alone, by providing that the Act would apply only to village administration and not land administration, that the traditional post of Myntri would also be known as Rangbah Shnong or Headman, and that a three-year term would be fixed for the Myntri.
The petitioners argued that a Myntri in Hima Maharam is not a Rangbah Shnong and that the Amendment effectively demoted the Myntri. They also said the Bill was introduced without seeking the opinion of the Dorbar Hima.
After the Bill was passed, the Maharam Syiemship filed objections before the Governor. In February 2021, the District Council Affairs Department told the KHADC that the Bill had not received assent and should be reconsidered. In August 2023, the State Law Department advised that Clause 2 on land and Clause 3 equating Myntri with Rangbah Shnong should be omitted.
Instead of placing the returned Bill before the full House, the KHADC Executive Committee, by letter dated September 1, 2023, said it had incorporated the Law Department’s observations and resubmitted the Bill. Clause 2 was omitted, but the controversial provisions on Myntri were retained. The Governor gave assent on September 15, 2023, and the Act was gazetted on September 26, 2023.
Senior Advocate HL Shangreiso for the petitioners argued that the Executive Committee cannot become the author of a law by amending it on its own. Senior Advocate Kaustav Paul for the KHADC and Advocate General Amit Kumar for the state contended that there was no formal return by the Governor, only Law Department observations, and the changes were merely clerical.
The court rejected that argument. It held that the return of the Bill was a formal act under Rule 93, not a routine administrative exchange. Rule 93 mandates that a returned Bill be placed by the Chairman before the Council for discussion and vote before resubmission to the Governor.
The court held, “This letter in the opinion of this Court, clearly establishes the fact that the substantial amendments which were made, were not merely clerical as contended by the respondents, were never placed before the Chairman of the House for discussion or vote, which is a clear transgression of the executive into the legislative domain of the Council.”
The Court concluded, “The Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) (Amendment) Act, 2019, is hereby declared as ultra vires on the ground of a fatal departure from the mandatory legislative procedure prescribed by Rule 93 of the Rules of 1951.”
With the Amendment struck down, the original 2006 Act revives for Hima Maharam. In Raid Saw Symper, a Myntri does not become a Rangbah Shnong, and the three-year term does not apply. The ruling lays down for KHADC, JHADC and GHADC that no Executive Committee can amend a Bill after the Governor returns it without a vote in the full House.























