Shillong, Nov 18: The Meghalaya High Court has flagged glaring discrepancies between affidavits filed by the State police before it and before the Supreme Court on CCTV cameras in police stations, and directed the Assistant Inspector General of Police (Administration) to appear before it with the contract files.
A division bench of Chief Justice Revati Mohite Dere and Justice Wanlura Diengdoh passed the order on November 10 in a PIL filed by Kishan K Nongkynrih and criminal petition by Anius Majhong.
Ri Bhoi Superintendent of Police Giri Prasad in an affidavit before the court stated that although the CCTV system was installed at Nongpoh Police Station, the cameras were not functioning at the time of the incident, relating to the death by suicide of a minor girl after being interrogated at the Nongpoh Women Police Station on June 22, 2026.
The chart submitted along with the affidavit showed that the problem was not limited to Nongpoh. At Umsning, 18 cameras installed in December 2023 were all non-functional since last year. At Umiam, 15 cameras installed in March 2023 were all non-functional since August 23, 2024. At Khanapara, 15 cameras installed in March 2023 were all non-functional since July 2026. At Nongpoh Police Station and Women Police Station, Nongpoh, 20 cameras installed in July 2021 were all non-functional since October 1, 2021. At Umsohlait, 12 cameras installed in March 2022 were all non-functional since May 30, 2022. Only Patharkhmah showed all cameras as functional.
The reasons cited included power fluctuation, low voltage, no UPS backup and UPS disorder.
This contradicted an affidavit by AIG (Administration) Dr. Sacheng R Marak before the Supreme Court on November 14, 2025, claiming “full compliance” and that all 81 police stations had functional CCTV since October 2023, at a cost of Rs. 10,65,46,082.
Counsel for the petitioner, N Khera told the court that the state had claimed 1,142 CCTV cameras were installed at a cost of around Rs. 10.65 crore between 2021 and 2024, but had not disclosed the terms of the contract, to whom it was awarded, whether the contractor was blacklisted, or whether there was an AMC clause. He also submitted that some cameras became non-functional within three months of installation.
The court found “some substance” in the submissions on discrepancies in statements made on oath, and directed the AIG “to remain present on the next date alongwith the files pertaining to the contract awarded of CCTV cameras installations.”
He has also been directed to file a detailed affidavit to explain the discrepancies and the non-functioning of CCTV cameras in various police stations and the steps that will be taken to ensure that there is compliance of the directions given by the Apex Court in the case of Paramvir Singh (Supra).
The court made it clear that the affidavit must contain details of “the date of installation of the CCTV cameras in the Police Stations, since when they are operational and since when they are non-functional, and the reasons for the same.”
The NIA has also been directed to file an affidavit on CCTV in its office. The matter will be heard next on November 30.






















